2023 Premier sfc

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

Fair enough Jimmy can you quote me the specific bye laws in relation to parishes crossing county bounds?

I’d only be delighted to be educated further.

You are the guy saying that where a county boundary crosses through a parish then the parish boundary rule does not apply..
I and others here have repeatedly asked you to
1) Provide the specific details of the case you are talking about
2) Provide the rule that supports your own opinion about all of this.. no one else is aware of it..

You can’t or won’t provide the info above but continue to argue, largely with yourself

 

[bluesball]

Barrs for the County

 

[WCJoe]

Yes Barrs to win it outright. Will be interesting to see how clon fair with nemo. No doubt luke is having sleepless nights already like Brian Hurley

 

[WCJoe]

Anyone hear anything about Tom Clancy and why he wasn't in action last weekend?

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

Anyone hear anything about Tom Clancy and why he wasn't in action last weekend?

Not taking his self removal from the proc well is what I heard

 

[fruice]

I have posted the information Johnnie lived in county cork but played gaa in county Kerry which was very close to his home but his permanent residence was county cork
He played in county Kerry for a period underage after under 12 but by rule 6.3 you must play in the county and moved to a club in Cork the county of his residence.

Cork bye law 32 refers directly back to GAA Rule 6.3 and defines first club being within in the county of your permanent residence.

It also states that Catchment Area (which may be determined by references to parishes) are subjected to county boundaries.

 

[TheEarlofPearl]

Anyone know why Clancy didn't play?

Anyone hear anything about Tom Clancy and why he wasn't in action last weekend?

Hmmm

 

[Boom Boom Boy]

Word from down west is Clonakilty have big injury concerns ahead of Nemo game on Saturday - 2 key inter county footballers injured playing Junior hurling while Clancy did his ankle badly at start of Castlehaven game - not ideal prep - they won't ever get a better chance to take Nemos scalp, game on in West Cork & Nemos c'ship form is probably the poorset it's been in years.

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

I have posted the information Johnnie lived in county cork but played gaa in county Kerry which was very close to his home but his permanent residence was county cork
He played in county Kerry for a period underage after under 12 but by rule 6.3 you must play in the county and moved to a club in Cork the county of his residence.

Cork bye law 32 refers directly back to GAA Rule 6.3 and defines first club being within in the county of your permanent residence.

It also states that Catchment Area (which may be determined by references to parishes) are subjected to county boundaries.

Thank you for finally providing some details.
Pity you didn’t say it was county Kerry at the outset you were talking about. This is a Cork forum obviously.
The player you referred to was trying to play football in county Kerry and under Kerry bye laws he had no entitlement to register as a player there.
Kerry have a very different approach which explains the outcome in the case you referenced
Unlike Cork, In Kerry you can only join the club in the parish in which you permanently reside unless you live in an open area (an area or parish with no club or more than one club). They have a very strict parish rule.
If you can’t prove permanent residence in a Kerry parish you can’t join the club in that parish.. Cork bye laws are very different.
To summarize, that boy who lives in Cork and totally contrary to the clear rules of Co Kerry he tried to play football in a Kerry parish even though he doesn’t live in. Yerra, they sent him back to Cork

 

[fruice]

Thank you for finally providing some details.
Pity you didn’t say it was county Kerry at the outset you were talking about. This is a Cork forum obviously.
The player you referred to was trying to play football in county Kerry and under Kerry bye laws he had no entitlement to register as a player there.
Kerry have a very different approach which explains the outcome in the case you referenced
Unlike Cork, In Kerry you can only join the club in the parish in which you permanently reside unless you live in an open area (an area or parish with no club or more than one club). They have a very strict parish rule.
If you can’t prove permanent residence in a Kerry parish you can’t join the club in that parish.. Cork bye laws are very different.
To summarize, that boy who lives in Cork and totally contrary to the clear rules of Co Kerry he tried to play football in a Kerry parish even though he doesn’t live in. Yerra, they sent him back to Cork

Yea 100% but if the scenario was reversed he wouldn’t be aloud play in Cork also ave would have to go back to Kerry.

But there is an exception to the rule do you know it?