2023 Premier sfc

R&B I think you are wasting your time trying to explain anything to this dude.. He has spent the last 2 days putting umpteen messages into a Cork GAA forum about a boy playing football and revealed only today that it all happened in another county entirely and has nothing at all whatsoever to do with Cork GAA… and despite this been clearly pointed out to him he continues messaging here about players breaking Cork GAA rules but hasn’t given a single example…

Maybe he's concerned if he gives an example you may warn him of degrading players like you stated to me, I have since taken your advice and read the rules. I am not enlightened much and nothing trigers me to change my mind on the rule book, transfers and the so-called 'Parish Rule'. Firstly there is no mention of 'Parish Rule' but there is of Catchment Area' and 'Permanent Residence ' Regarding the latter I am aware of a player who transferred from one club to another while living in a temporary residence all within Cork county and after the transfer went through he went to live in a permanent residence in Co. Limerick. As I stated to you in a former post I am long gone from within club affairs but at the time I can only recall the transfer being approved by the North Cork Juvenile Divisional Board without involvement from County Board. Rule 6.1 referring to the considered allegiance & loyalty to the players first Club I understand has been broken many a time but it's phrased as a consideration and not a compellant. Also it begs the question when did the rule first come into effect?
 
Last edited:
Maybe he's concerned if he gives an example you may warn him of degrading players like you stated to me, I have since taken your advice and read the rules. I am not enlightened much and nothing trigers me to change my mind on the rule book, transfers and the so-called 'Parish Rule'. Firstly there is no mention of 'Parish Rule' but there is of Catchment Area' and 'Permanent Residence ' Regarding the latter I am aware of a player who transferred from one club to another while living in a temporary residence all within Cork county and after the transfer went through he went to live in a permanent residence in Co. Limerick. As I stated to you in a former post I am long gone from within club affairs but at the time I can only recall the transfer being approved by the North Cork Juvenile Divisional Board without involvement from County Board. Rule 6.1 referring to the considered allegiance & loyalty to the players first Club I understand has been broken many a time but it's phrased as a consideration and not a compellant. Also it begs the question when did the rule first come into effect?
Didn’t he give a very specific example…
It was for a boy that played under 12 football in Kerry in breach of the Kerry County Boards bye laws. When he gave the details it was blatantly obvious that his example had nothing at all to do with Cork GAA.
I can’t comment on what went on at an unknown time in the past that you are referencing.. I’m not sure how or why you want to take me back there.
Instead of asking me to help you make your point, Maybe you might set it the incident you are referring to, when it took place, the exact rules at the time and explain to us how and when the rules have changed since.
 
Maybe he's concerned if he gives an example you may warn him of degrading players like you stated to me, I have since taken your advice and read the rules. I am not enlightened much and nothing trigers me to change my mind on the rule book, transfers and the so-called 'Parish Rule'. Firstly there is no mention of 'Parish Rule' but there is of Catchment Area' and 'Permanent Residence ' Regarding the latter I am aware of a player who transferred from one club to another while living in a temporary residence all within Cork county and after the transfer went through he went to live in a permanent residence in Co. Limerick. As I stated to you in a former post I am long gone from within club affairs but at the time I can only recall the transfer being approved by the North Cork Juvenile Divisional Board without involvement from County Board. Rule 6.1 referring to the considered allegiance & loyalty to the players first Club I understand has been broken many a time but it's phrased as a consideration and not a compellant. Also it begs the question when did the rule first come into effect?
How is the catchment area defined in Cork?
If it’s not the parish boundary then what is it?
 
Yes it applys to Kerry GAA but it also applies to Cork GAA the rule is clear you must have “permanent residence” within in the county to play there.


I have posted the rule book do what you please after that.
I can’t help you anymore than I already have.. you have your own rule book or a unique interpretation of the rule book & by laws that the rest of us adhere to.
Just in this years championship alone players with permanent addresses in Limerick, Tipperary, Waterford and Kerry have played.
I’ll have to leave it there I’m afraid..
 

EVENT GUIDE - HIGHLIGHT
Coco Comedy Club: Kyla Cobbler and Guests
The Roundy, Castle St.

24th Nov 2023 @ 8:30 pm
More info..
View more events ▼
Top