2023 Premier sfc

[bluesball]

Barrs Still for the county

 

[bluesball]

The Camogie R & B.

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

Yes it applys to Kerry GAA but it also applies to Cork GAA the rule is clear you must have “permanent residence” within in the county to play there.


I have posted the rule book do what you please after that.

I can’t help you anymore than I already have.. you have your own rule book or a unique interpretation of the rule book & by laws that the rest of us adhere to.
Just in this years championship alone players with permanent addresses in Limerick, Tipperary, Waterford and Kerry have played.
I’ll have to leave it there I’m afraid..

 

[fruice]

I can’t help you anymore than I already have.. you have your own rule book or a unique interpretation of the rule book & by laws that the rest of us adhere to.
Just in this years championship alone players with permanent addresses in Limerick, Tipperary, Waterford and Kerry have played.
I’ll have to leave it there I’m afraid..

You haven’t really helped you have served to malign and make fun of me while also refusing to quote the rule book.

Yes players with permanent address in these counties have played in the Cork Championship but there is specific situations where this allowed for within the rule book.

But on the example given here of the boy with a permanent residence in Limerick but going to school in Charleville and has zero ties to Cork and wanting to play with his pals he can’t as by rule he should play in Limerick

 

[Boom Boom Boy]

Agree on Barrs being short favourites, would prob have Castlehaven closer to Nemo in the betting than they are, cant see any of the rest really rattling it - as an outside bet Douglas at 7/1 (each way) to make the Final might be a bit of value

 

[Roaming Role]

Agree on Barrs being short favourites, would prob have Castlehaven closer to Nemo in the betting than they are, cant see any of the rest really rattling it - as an outside bet Douglas at 7/1 (each way) to make the Final might be a bit of value

View attachment 24926

Barrs will win it handy. Whoever wins Clon/Nemo will be with them in the final. Douglas won't make it past Michael's Friday night, knockout football now they won't have the bottle.

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

But on the example given here of the boy with a permanent residence in Limerick but going to school in Charleville and has zero ties to Cork and wanting to play with his pals he can’t as by rule he should play in Limerick

Put up the rule for Cork GAA on this that supports your view?
You are using Kerry by laws which are different to Corks.
Going round in circles here!!

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

Agree on Barrs being short favourites, would prob have Castlehaven closer to Nemo in the betting than they are, cant see any of the rest really rattling it - as an outside bet Douglas at 7/1 (each way) to make the Final might be a bit of value

View attachment 24926

Barr’s unless there is a massive slip up..
I’d have The Haven closer too but they haven’t been going well. I can understand the bookies take.. Their main group of players are getting old now, into their 30s and it’s 10 years since they won it.

 

[fruice]

Put up the rule for Cork GAA on this that supports your view?
You are using Kerry by laws which are different to Corks.
Going round in circles here!!

Kerry bye laws differ slightly to Cork bye laws but both require permanent residence to play for a club within the county.

If anything it’s you who are quoting Kerry bye laws as they give specific mention to the parish which you have constantly mentioned

Rule 32 (“first club”)in Cork bye of laws refers back to GAA Rule 6.3 and backs up my point of view which I have previously posted.

Unless you can show me a ruling within in law to back up your point of view like I have done.

I’ll just take it you don’t understand the rules completely.

 

[JimmyBarrySmurph]

Kerry bye laws differ slightly to Cork bye laws but both require permanent residence to play for a club within the county.

If anything it’s you who are quoting Kerry bye laws as they give specific mention to the parish which you have constantly mentioned

Rule 32 (“first club”)in Cork bye of laws refers back to GAA Rule 6.3 and backs up my point of view which I have previously posted.

Unless you can show me a ruling within in law to back up your point of view like I have done.

I’ll just take it you don’t understand the rules completely.

My lord!! You’ve lost the arguement long ago. You were referring to a case in a different County. What happens to a boy in Kerry has nothing to do with us..
A for the rules in Cork & Kerry being Slightly different!!!???? ???

Your “first club” in Cork is the club you play your first game with at U12. It can be any club anywhere in the county, regardless of where you live. You can also have played with any number of other clubs prior to this first game at U12 with your “first club”. If you want to move clubs after establishing your “first club” you will have to satisfy the transfer rules.

Kerry is the total opposite. You can only play with the club in the parish in which you permanently reside. This is regardless of your age.