Cork Minor Hurling 2023

[Pooman]

From the article in todays examiner I'm not confident that CCB are going to make things any better next year.

“We all know the U18 grade is an absolute cornerstone of the GAA. We do need an U18 competition [in 2023],” O’Donovan told the meeting.
“It will be a hybrid version. It might have to be short. It might have to be knockout. It can’t be a full program of meaningful games without decoupling. It just can’t. However, I do think there should be a moratorium on decoupling for the full year of 2023.”

Does this mean that they are just proposing to swap the unsuccessful U19 competitions this year to U18 next year?
I would assume U17 would also have to stay as a primary grade so those lads would get a full league and championship structure similar to current formats?

Majority of Cork GAA clubs in favour of minor returning to under 18

At the end of Tuesday night’s special Cork county board meeting to ascertain the views of Cork clubs on their preferred minor age-grade, Cork secretary Kevin O’Donovan called for a moratorium on decoupling at U18 until 2024.

www.irishexaminer.com

It's all a bit of a mess alright.
The sooner minor reverts to U18 the better.
Interestingly though the Barrs would have had no Ben O'Connor or William Buckley this year if minor was U18.

 

[Corkonian1]

From the article in todays examiner I'm not confident that CCB are going to make things any better next year.

“We all know the U18 grade is an absolute cornerstone of the GAA. We do need an U18 competition [in 2023],” O’Donovan told the meeting.
“It will be a hybrid version. It might have to be short. It might have to be knockout. It can’t be a full program of meaningful games without decoupling. It just can’t. However, I do think there should be a moratorium on decoupling for the full year of 2023.”

Does this mean that they are just proposing to swap the unsuccessful U19 competitions this year to U18 next year?
I would assume U17 would also have to stay as a primary grade so those lads would get a full league and championship structure similar to current formats?

Majority of Cork GAA clubs in favour of minor returning to under 18

At the end of Tuesday night’s special Cork county board meeting to ascertain the views of Cork clubs on their preferred minor age-grade, Cork secretary Kevin O’Donovan called for a moratorium on decoupling at U18 until 2024.

www.irishexaminer.com

If they do swap then U-18 is better to have because more U-19 players are playing at adult level anyway. The U-19 competition was not a success this year in Cork particularly in hurling. However if congress goes back to U-18 then one would expect the U-19 to become redundant.

 

[leeside_rebel]

Everyone wants u18 back but the problem seems to be smaller clubs also want to be able to play the u18 on their adult team

Would it work to have a different rule depending on grade?

Junior clubs can use 18 year olds but senior/intermediate can't? Or would that be a mess too

 

[BBAWS]

Everyone wants u18 back but the problem seems to be smaller clubs also want to be able to play the u18 on their adult team

Would it work to have a different rule depending on grade?

Junior clubs can use 18 year olds but senior/intermediate can't? Or would that be a mess too

Or maybe have a threshold of numbers and make it that if under 18s are eligible then they can only play with the top team at adult level. Also, if a club has 30 players paying membership at adult level then they shouldn’t qualify for using an under 18.

 

[leeside_rebel]

Or maybe have a threshold of numbers and make it that if under 18s are eligible then they can only play with the top team at adult level. Also, if a club has 30 players paying membership at adult level then they shouldn’t qualify for using an under 18.

If they can find something that suits the small rural clubs with limited numbers then I'd imagine it will definitely return to u18

 

[The Fisherman 2]

Rebel Og have a very simple proposal:

U18s can play adult OR u18 but not both.
Let the clubs decide then.
If they are interested in Long Term Player Development there should be no issues.

 

[Vladimir The Bear]

Can't understand why lads can't play both minor and adult. I think the whole change up of the minor grade a few years back had been a disaster. I didn't think it was broken so there was no need to fix it. There was no need to tinker with the U21 grade either. U18 and U21 were two fantastic grades that have been greatly diminished.

If its burn out they were worried about then fix the college GAA season to alleviate that. Bring in a rule, no player involved with a college is allowed to play inter county games while his college is still in their respective competition.

If its drop out rates they are worried about, then they need to realise that some lads will drop out regardless of that they do. Why can't minor club games be played on a Wednesday night, all adult games on weekends. No reason why a 17/18 year old can't play 2 club games 3/4 days apart week in, week out for the summer. It would be more enjoyable then training anyway.

 

[Pooman]

Can't understand why lads can't play both minor and adult. I think the whole change up of the minor grade a few years back had been a disaster. I didn't think it was broken so there was no need to fix it. There was no need to tinker with the U21 grade either. U18 and U21 were two fantastic grades that have been greatly diminished.

If its burn out they were worried about then fix the college GAA season to alleviate that. Bring in a rule, no player involved with a college is allowed to play inter county games while his college is still in their respective competition.

If its drop out rates they are worried about, then they need to realise that some lads will drop out regardless of that they do. Why can't minor club games be played on a Wednesday night, all adult games on weekends. No reason why a 17/18 year old can't play 2 club games 3/4 days apart week in, week out for the summer. It would be more enjoyable then training anyway.

The main problem is not the number of games but the training sessions fellas are expected to attend as well. I have two involved with school, club, divisional & county underage squads. Zero joined up thinking. Everyone expecting their team to be the priority. Shower of muppets, don't care that they're burning out the kids.

 

[Dinger]

Lads are allowed to, and do play a year up all the way up to minor. Change minor to U18 and let them play the next age beyond (adult).

 

[Corkonian1]

What is the idea of the U-16 Championship so late, is it to keep players playing hurling over soccer and rugby? It interferes with players on the Cork minor squad unless they're exempt or can come and go as they please which I don't approve. I believe players in both codes up to inter-county U-16 decided recently between hurling and football for the Cork minor panels but I only heard of one player who chose hurling.