Your second point makes zero sense hurly - don’t see any connection to paul Murphy’s dopey prediction ??
Re your first point, I totally disagree. BC (imo) is in the same bracket as Patrick Fitzgerald, Joyce, Screeny, Austin gleeson - lads with enough talent for senior IC championship at a young age. There’s prob only a handful of them around the country each year. Yes he’s been injured but he was fit last weekend and would have been worth a bench spot. Waterford had 2 lads younger than him playing, one of whom missed most of the league through injury.