• Here, if you give a thumbs up or similarly positive reaction to a racist comment you may also receive a ban along with the user that wrote the post.

Cork Hurlers - Part 2

Good analysis. I mostly agree. Mark can’t be the 7.
Maybe Sean Desmond is worth a look at. He has had some excellent games.
Also if he recaptures form Brian Roche could be considered for wing forward or midfield
Sean Desmond definitely worth a look at but the jump to inter county is so big it takes a few years to adjust. We seem to write fellas off on here after one bad performance ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JPM
The Cork senior hurlers have issues in defence for a very long time because selectors have been poor and have not addressed those issues. Under Kieran Kingston's management twice and John Meyler & Pat Ryan, a total of 4 managements have selected and played Mark Coleman at 7 mostly and otherwise at 6. How long should it take for them to see the writing on the wall along with the issues at corner-back? It was disgraceful that Conor O'Sullivan and Stephen McDonnell were discarded but the fact remains that natural corner-backs like them don't exist in the county, therefore they have to be manufactured. To do this the attributes required for playing at 2 or 4 have to be assessed and players who already have inter-county experience should be first looked at for those positions rather than playing players out of underage who didn't play in those positions or haven't stood out showing senior inter-county credentials. From underage now and over the past few years I think there are only a few players outside the senior squad and the most obvious is Timmy Wilk to develop into an inter-county corner-back and I state develop because it's not his most natural position. However I believe the Cork management have enough talent firstly within the squad to look at players who have been involved for a while, they need to insure starts for players like Tommy O'Connell and Brian Roche in the team over a few league games or a campaign and the question begs why not play them corner-back? Both of them are tenacious and quick, O'Connell's hurling has stood out often including the AI final in July and Roche was a MOM recipient in senior championship in 2023 but both don't seem to be regarded enough by management for some reason along with the management not thinking outside the box in addressing problematic issues. Eoin Roche is another option that needs to be tried although I believe Tommy and Brian have more hurling to be tidier in this position. Cillian Tobin stood out at wing-back and also when he moved to centre-back for the Cork U-20's this year so why shouldn't he be looked at as a corner-back for the seniors. As a longer term option he may be more suited to full-back than the corner with Eoin Downey corner-back or wing-back. Niall O'Leary had an improved year in 2024 and will be the choice of most and likely the selectors to start corner-back v Wexford but a bolder selection where everyone should learn more from is Brian Roche at 2 and Tommy O'Connell at 4 with either Daire O'Leary or Ger Millerick at 7, the remainder of the defence were first choice in this years championship.
 
Old fart keyboard warriors know better than the manager and selectors who spend every training session, matches, even club games watching players.
F8cken scenes ?????
 
I was sitting right by the pitch when Fitzgerald got the ball and as bad as Coleman's defence was, it was criminal that he was marking Fitzgerald for this play. In fact he wasn't the one marking Fitzgerald before this but Fitzgerald saw the opportunity to win a puck out over Coleman and made his way to left half forward.

I know it happens fast but the Cork players need to think fast and no way should Coleman ever be isolated on the wing against any player who is strong in the air. If it means conceding one short and someone drops back to cover 2 v 1 then so be it. This goal could have been prevented before it happened, and of course should still have been prevented as it happened. At this level you should be absolutely tuned in for everything.

Also, for Rodgers goal, Sean O'D had him hooked but last second decided to go for a block. Ultimately they were two soft goals that looked like great goals for Clare.
this is a bit mad.
if Coleman cant defend a puck out regardless of who is on him he cant play wing back. full stop. Fitzgerald isnt even that good in the air by the way
 
The Cork senior hurlers have issues in defence for a very long time because selectors have been poor and have not addressed those issues. Under Kieran Kingston's management twice and John Meyler & Pat Ryan, a total of 4 managements have selected and played Mark Coleman at 7 mostly and otherwise at 6. How long should it take for them to see the writing on the wall along with the issues at corner-back? It was disgraceful that Conor O'Sullivan and Stephen McDonnell were discarded but the fact remains that natural corner-backs like them don't exist in the county, therefore they have to be manufactured. To do this the attributes required for playing at 2 or 4 have to be assessed and players who already have inter-county experience should be first looked at for those positions rather than playing players out of underage who didn't play in those positions or haven't stood out showing senior inter-county credentials. From underage now and over the past few years I think there are only a few players outside the senior squad and the most obvious is Timmy Wilk to develop into an inter-county corner-back and I state develop because it's not his most natural position. However I believe the Cork management have enough talent firstly within the squad to look at players who have been involved for a while, they need to insure starts for players like Tommy O'Connell and Brian Roche in the team over a few league games or a campaign and the question begs why not play them corner-back? Both of them are tenacious and quick, O'Connell's hurling has stood out often including the AI final in July and Roche was a MOM recipient in senior championship in 2023 but both don't seem to be regarded enough by management for some reason along with the management not thinking outside the box in addressing problematic issues. Eoin Roche is another option that needs to be tried although I believe Tommy and Brian have more hurling to be tidier in this position. Cillian Tobin stood out at wing-back and also when he moved to centre-back for the Cork U-20's this year so why shouldn't he be looked at as a corner-back for the seniors. As a longer term option he may be more suited to full-back than the corner with Eoin Downey corner-back or wing-back. Niall O'Leary had an improved year in 2024 and will be the choice of most and likely the selectors to start corner-back v Wexford but a bolder selection where everyone should learn more from is Brian Roche at 2 and Tommy O'Connell at 4 with either Daire O'Leary or Ger Millerick at 7, the remainder of the defence were first choice in this years championship.
Conor o sullivan is not a good intercounty corner back.
In fact when clare and cork reached the all ireland final in 2013 fitzgerald, for the first time , played patrick donnellan as a midfielder and not a sweeper left Colin Ryan at wing forward and pushed conor mcgrath right up so conor o sullivan had to mark him and therefore couldnt sweep which is what he wanted to do
 
EVENT GUIDE - HIGHLIGHT
The Lee Sessions Trad Trail
JJ Walsh's, 64 Oliver Plunkett St.

12th Jul 2025 @ 7:00 pm
More info..

Ceili By The Lee

Crane Lane Theatre, Tomorrow @ 7:30pm

More events ▼
Top