I have to admire one thing about your argument and that is you did not suggest that either posters were Gay, had mental issues or could not play GAA games while they were younger.
Just I can say for sure that if one had posted anything negative about that cult 5 years ago on this forum that is exactly what would have been said.
I know because it was directed at me, not that I give or gave a care.
Anyway, that place is an absolute waste of money and I agree with the suggestion that it should be ran by an independent body and be open to all and every sport.
But with the dinosaurs running that cult I cannot see that happening anytime soon.