The Hurling Thread

[TheEarlofPearl]

I don't have a bee in any of my bonnets.
I was replying to your post and pointed out that discussion on a discussion forum is more or less what you would expect.

I also pointed to two instances where the exclusion of Cork players is difficult to explain. I think both of those were unusual and controversial.

It is possible to have an opinion on something you have little regard for.

Hardly difficult to explain, the people picking the team that year thought Cooper and Coulter had a better season than him. Picking Allstars is opinion based and subjective not some bias or conspiracy theory.

 

[North Cork]

Hardly difficult to explain, the people picking the team that year thought Cooper and Coulter had a better season than him. Picking Allstars is opinion based and subjective not some bias or conspiracy theory.

I accept that, but if I recall correctly Kerry were beaten in the quarter finals in 2010 and Goulding was absolutely vital to Cork in their All Ireland win.

I think if the roles had been reversed there would have been mayhem.

 

[TheEarlofPearl]

I accept that, but if I recall correctly Kerry were beaten in the quarter finals in 2010 and Goulding was absolutely vital to Cork in their All Ireland win.

I think if the roles had been reversed there would have been mayhem.

See that is the point I am getting at, there wouldn't be mayhem as no one really gives a shite about the all stars.
If maybe it was picked exclusively by players like the FOTY/HOTY then it may have some credibility but in it's current form, it's a glorified club dinner dance.

 

[North Cork]

See that is the point I am getting at, there wouldn't be mayhem as no one really gives a shite about the all stars.
If maybe it was picked exclusively by players like the FOTY/HOTY then it may have some credibility but in it's current form, it's a glorified club dinner dance.

We can certainly agree on that.

 

[hurley68]

JJ Delaney joining Cats U20 backroom set up
Some hurler in his day

 

[imigrant]

JJ Delaney joining Cats U20 backroom set up
Some hurler in his day

For me . The best of all time. Play anywhere (including full back). Mark anyone. Overcome injury. Kept Ben quiet.

 

[TheEarlofPearl]

JJ Delaney joining Cats U20 backroom set up
Some hurler in his day

Legend

 

[Pooman]

For me . The best of all time. Play anywhere (including full back). Mark anyone. Overcome injury. Kept Ben quiet.

For me that KK team had 3 all-time geats, Henry, Tommy & JJ. Always thought he didn't get as much recognition as the other 2 because he had to go in full-back when at the time he was the best half-back in the country. Some player.

 

[Gregory_Mike]

JJ Delaney joining Cats U20 backroom set up
Some hurler in his day

A humble guy and a much better pundit than any of the RTE up their own arses bores too.

 

[HurlingFan19]

For me that KK team had 3 all-time geats, Henry, Tommy & JJ. Always thought he didn't get as much recognition as the other 2 because he had to go in full-back when at the time he was the best half-back in the country. Some player.

Best defender of all time