Fair enough a year isn’t overly significantHayes is 26 this year, Downey is 25 this year
Hayes and Hegarty are built like trucks
Fair enough a year isn’t overly significantHayes is 26 this year, Downey is 25 this year
I was very disappointed with the 2cd half performance last Sunday, same as everyone here but I do think there has been a complete over reaction from some as to the performance. It was the 4th of February and leaving aside that we played a very good Clare team in their home patch people should bear in mind that the team last Sunday won't be anything close to the team come championship. I would argue there was guys playing last Sunday that won't even be close to the panel come the end of the league let alone championship.
I was a bit annoyed with the team that was picked for the trip to Ennis. Now obviously I'm not privy to the inner goings on in the panel and who was available and who wasn't etc but I thought our forward line in particular looked like a stale selection. We have been down the route of Kingston and Lehane so many times before in the same forward line, It doesn't work come crunch time so why even bother try it again for a league game in 2024, nothing to be learned from it.
I also felt our midfield was far too lightweight/ inexperienced for a trip to Ennis.
Also as well and all as Tommy O Connell played, Pat Ryan is surely not going to go down the route of playing him wing back again in championship knowing that a Gearoid Hegarty or Tony Kelly etc is going to be put on him immediately. I think there is a place for Tommy in the starting 15, but at midfield.
If the same panel is all that's available again for next Saturday night then I'd like to see a starting 15 of
Collins
C O Callaghan, E Roche, S O Donaghue
G Millerick, C Joyce, E Downey
T O Connell, M Mullins
B Roche, S Barrett, S Twomey
R O Flynn, Hoggie, B Hayes.
Ya, on reflection that would probably be a better idea. It would be more balanced and much more experienced midfield.Good post, and I like that team. But I also like RighthandofRing's suggestion to play Meade at midfield alongside O'Connell, to provide a bit more experience. Bring on Mullins at HT.
In 2013, 5 Clare players won back to back U21 All Irelands, 2 weeks prior to the senior replay.
All of those 5, 4 were actually U20s and It was a 19-year-old Shane O Donnell who stole the show in that senior replay.
Davy moulded his champions that year around a young spine, the defensive rock David McInerney (20) through the commanding Colm Galvin (20) in midfield up to Tony Kelly (19) and Podge Collins (21) in the forwards.
We are a million mixed heads away from producing that type of talent in my opinion
Rob Downey has established himself at IC level and last year was his best imo which shows he is going in the right direction. Eoin was still U20 last year and his one ch'ship game v Tipp showed how difficult the step up is, still has what it takes imo. I think Brian Hayes has an outside chance of making it as an inter county starterBrian Hayes will be 23 this year . Rob Downey 25 .....Eoin Downey 21