Do you not agree that somebody who loses a nightclub job would be probably be financially and socially as well
off in a daytime hospitality job?
I think that would depend on what their skill-set is. Being a large imposing tattooed door-man for instance mightn't really lend itself to showing people to their seats and waiting on tables. Or being a DJ or band member or roadie. Even bar staff that are used to working the night shift - what are they supposed to do now with the numbers of bars opened already reduced - should they just tell their day-time colleagues not to bother coming in?
A one-size fits all system won't work and while the PUP may be discouraging a certain cohort of people from returning to work - construction experts tell us that we don't have enough construction workers anyway even if each and every one of them was back at work - reducing the PUP while at the same time removing some people's ability to actually go to their work is stupid.