The Gaelic Football Thread

[rebel without a caus]

CCCC reaks of corruption.
Love to know how much they get in brown envelopes.

 

[Lee Bushwacker]

I am.
End result has to be taken into account even if intent is equal.
Comer will be able to play the semi final with Galway.
The mallow player would not have played championship 2 weeks after the incident with Kelly.

Extreme example here, but If two people with a gun go out to kill someone, both fire but one misses their target and one hits their target. Are they charged the same? No, one is murder but the other is attempted murder. Both receive a sentence but one is lesser as a result of outcome

The intent to cause serious injury ie gouging was clearly shown by the Armagh scumbag. Should have got 1-2 years ban imo.

 

[TheOutdoorThreadmill]

I am.
End result has to be taken into account even if intent is equal.
Comer will be able to play the semi final with Galway.
The mallow player would not have played championship 2 weeks after the incident with Kelly.

Extreme example here, but If two people with a gun go out to kill someone, both fire but one misses their target and one hits their target. Are they charged the same? No, one is murder but the other is attempted murder. Both receive a sentence but one is lesser as a result of outcome

Only because his teammate intervened to prevent a more serious injury. Gouging is a despicable act and the CCCC are giving carte blanche now to players with this nonsense ban. Never mind that they didn't even look at the fact that he shouldn't have been there. He won't even miss a game with Armagh. What message is that sending out

 

[hurley68]

I am.
End result has to be taken into account even if intent is equal.
Comer will be able to play the semi final with Galway.
The mallow player would not have played championship 2 weeks after the incident with Kelly.

Extreme example here, but If two people with a gun go out to kill someone, both fire but one misses their target and one hits their target. Are they charged the same? No, one is murder but the other is attempted murder. Both receive a sentence but one is lesser as a result of

You need to read up on a legal term
"Common design"
Get Matty to explain it to you

 

[imigrant]

Galway county board have confirmed Sean Kelly is available for the semi final

 

[jimmym]

Philly mcmahon says he is sick of the fake outrage after armagh v galway brawl,
He says gaa supporters love a brawl,
what a ridiculous attitude

 

[Gregory_Mike]

Philly mcmahon says he is sick of the fake outrage after armagh v galway brawl,
He says gaa supporters love a brawl,
what a ridiculous attitude

Says Philly, a former eye gouger himself.

 

[Hank Scorpio]

Very muted buildup to the Semis.

 

[jimmym]

Very muted buildup to the Semis.

6/4 Dublin is good value

 

[Hank Scorpio]

6/4 Dublin is good value

I'd bet the house on the Animals tbh.