Sex Education for Primary school....

[fed up]

I've often saw girls play in boys teams that went on to play at a high standard because of it.

Just my tuppence ha'penny observation like.

 

[dmc]

I've often saw girls play in boys teams that went on to play at a high standard because of it.

Just my tuppence ha'penny observation like.

Really strong chooses to play with the boys. Tell me you see how that is different a group of girls from strong to very weak being told they have accept a boy playing among them in their girls only team because the boy now identifies as a girl. A world of difference there.

 

[dahayeser]

I never suggested that a boy would change with girls in the first place so I couldn't have backed away from it.

If you mean treat a girl losing their place to a trans girl the same as losing it to a cis girl then yes. Having already said this 3 times, I can't understand how you could possibly need more clarification.

Trans girl, and yes they forfeit.

If they think its a safety issue let them take it up with the organisation.

TBH catching up on the posts I didn't see you say it clearly as you have here. You were ducking and diving behind, not your decision and finding an accommodation

Now your opinion is clear as day - boy says he is a girl, that's enough, he is in, treat the same as any real girl from now.

Dear god. This post is truly frightening. I am genuinely shocked.

What do the rest of the gender switching cheerleaders make of this? Are ye backing this too?

Well done @dmc you got the truth eventually

 

[dmc]

If you mean treat a girl losing their place to a trans girl the same as losing it to a cis girl then yes. Having already said this 3 times, I can't understand how you could possibly need more clarification.

Seriously!!! It's the same, are you nuts???

What has the boy done to prove he is a girl? NOTHING.

He said he feels like a girl. Firstly he couldn't possibly tell what it feels like to be a girl because he is biologically a boy.

This gender identity isn't observable nor testable. There is not a scrap of science to back up that this boy is a girl.

Trans girl, and yes they forfeit.

Most teams are going to forfeit. You will have no games. I'd imagine you have no connection to girls sports so you have no idea of the feeling on the ground (correct me if I am wrong here) but I can't think of a team where you are going to get enough parents to endorse this by letting their daughters play. So no games. That's fair on the real girls isn't it.

If they think its a safety issue let them take it up with the organisation.

You don't think it is a safety issue letting any boy who claims to be a girl to be immediately branded a "trans girl" and left free to play in the girls division? Once again are you actually serious here?

 

[Matlock]

TBH catching up on the posts I didn't see you say it clearly as you have here. You were ducking and diving behind, not your decision and finding an accommodation

Now your opinion is clear as day - boy says he is a girl, that's enough, he is in, treat the same as any real girl from now.

Dear god. This post is truly frightening. I am genuinely shocked.

What do the rest of the gender switching cheerleaders make of this? Are ye backing this too?

Well done @dmc you got the truth eventually

I have said the same thing over and over.

That thing was not this "boy says he is a girl, that's enough, he is in, treat the same as any real girl from now"

 

[Matlock]

Seriously!!! It's the same, are you nuts???

What has the boy done to prove he is a girl? NOTHING.

He said he feels like a girl. Firstly he couldn't possibly tell what it feels like to be a girl because he is biologically a boy.

This gender identity isn't observable nor testable. There is not a scrap of science to back up that this boy is a girl.

Those are not the tests for someone being trans though. I get that you don't agree.

Most teams are going to forfeit. You will have no games. I'd imagine you have no connection to girls sports so you have no idea of the feeling on the ground (correct me if I am wrong here) but I can't think of a team where you are going to get enough parents to endorse this by letting their daughters play. So no games. That's fair on the real girls isn't it.

You don't think it is a safety issue letting any boy who claims to be a girl to be immediately branded a "trans girl" and left free to play in the girls division? Once again are you actually serious here?

I don't know how many times I can say the same thing if you keep ignoring it. I have said over and over that past a certain age safety concerns need to take priority.

Sporting organisations will come up with rules about this. Some already have.

It is not that big of a deal, and it is a very small part of the life experience of trans person.

 

[Matlock]

I've often saw girls play in boys teams that went on to play at a high standard because of it.

Just my tuppence ha'penny observation like.

I played on a mixed teams until I was 12. No dressing room for any gender either!

 

[TheRebelRoar]

Long story short this strongly contested ideology should not be introduced in primary schools.

Why is it always about access to young children with these creeps?

 

[Matlock]

Long story short this strongly contested ideology should not be introduced in primary schools.

Why is it always about access to young children with these creeps?

Using words like "creeps" certainly shouldn't form part of the ideology of a primary school, or anywhere else really

 

[dahayeser]

I played on a mixed teams until I was 12. No dressing room for any gender either!

Stupid comment. I have often see a strong girl play with the boys even up to u14. Totally differet. The girl is not putting the boys in danger and she is she isn't pushing everyone accept her as a boy and looking to access changing facilities or any of that absurdity.

Douglas merged LGFA, GAA and Camogie to the One Club model. Year 1 they played u5 and u6 boys and girls together for street leagues finals to as the poster child for One Club. Never again they said it was a total disaster. Boys dominated all the games, only a handful of girls able to hold their own. Loads of weaker girls going off crying. That is u5 & u6. Boys are built different.

You want to open the door for 12 / 13 year old boys to play with the girls and then to tell them and their parents to suck it up if they don't like it.

No tests, no science, just boy says he is a girl. You are living in cloud cookoo land.