Do you really think so Cloudy?
I know he's barely had a chance and a transfer window might have changed things but they were doomed under him, IMO. They made a good start and only for that, they'd be gone already.
It's going to be a ridiculously tough job but it's not mission impossible for the new man. They're probably doomed but if they can get a new man in, along with the current transfer window to work with, it could all change. I don't think Phelan was the man for them in the long run either way. They're giving themselves a chance now. The appointment is obviously crucial.