Junior A Hurling Championship 2023

They had a couple of top players with Cork when I was playing back then.
Heard they are on the verge of going and heard that their Cork minor footballer earlier this year has already transferred to Mallow recently.

It’s a shame to see any club go. An amalgamation is only possible if the clubs involved are reasonably equal or if not equal the junior partner is realistic about what they have to offer and should benefit from the amalgamation.

2/3 proud clubs in that catchment area are all struggling, maybe you could see an amalgamation between those down the line
 
All too proud to amalgamate. People in each of those clubs for it and can see what's going to happen if they don't join with an another but many in the clubs don't want it either
these things depend on numbers at underage as an important factor too I would say. If you’re tight on numbers as it is and have little underage coming up then you don’t have a choice. If you are tight on numbers but have big underage maybe you can hold on and take a chance they’ll come good.
 
Doneraile played minor football recently and are playing minor hurling atm, can check this on the rebel og site. Player in question did play against the Barrs in p1 semifinal and it seems that he's going playing with mallow if rumours are true. Its unfortunate that Doneraile are in such a low state as it wouldn't be nice to see any club fold( can't really see this happening though as they'll probably keep fielding in JB football & hurling to survive), Doneraile beat Ballyclough in JB hurling championship last weekend so there must be some life left in them, also see on the Avondhu website they got beat well by Shanballymore few weeks ago in football championship.
 
They had a couple of top players with Cork when I was playing back then.
Heard they are on the verge of going and heard that their Cork minor footballer earlier this year has already transferred to Mallow recently.

It’s a shame to see any club go. An amalgamation is only possible if the clubs involved are reasonably equal or if not equal the junior partner is realistic about what they have to offer and should benefit from the amalgamation.
It is a shame to see Doneraile go the way they are going. Strong rumours now that they will have no team next year, by all accounts. A lot of their current team are opting out supposedly. Not sure if this is true but only speculation. But the club has been declining over the last 8 or 9 years so this is no shock.

Their decline is due to poor committees in the club over the last 10 or 15 years. Yes, there are one or two members doing trajan work to keep the show going but they need support and they need strong individuals in there to start the club from scratch and show leadership to get it out of the rut it is currently in.

It is widely known that the culture in the club is broken. There is an acceptance of mediocrity. Poor standards, no ambition, poor numbers training, poor attitude and poor discipline. This has led to the rot and I would imagine it is going to be a long road back for the club. Always strong at juvenile level and now they hardly have juvenile teams.

There has been talks of amalgamations for the last few years but no club has yet agreed to an amalgamation. That dying pride has to go out the window and getting competitive teams out on a pitch every week at both underage and adult level needs to be a priority.

It is a pity to see Doneraile go this way, a brilliant football team in the 80s and 90s and an excellent hurling team in the 00s and early 10s, with many representatives on Cork underage teams over the years. Castletownroche and Shanballymore are two proud GAA clubs who were both senior hurling clubs in the 1950s and 1960s, and have been very strong at junior level in the 90s and 00s, but numbers have been an issue there and are now feeling the pinch as their conveyor belt has dried up. You would say Shanballymore are the strongest of the three teams currently with some players playing and winning with St. Dominics (underage amalgamation with Glanworth). Ballyclough and Grange are two other clubs struggling, as mentioned above.

It will be an interesting winter in the committee rooms.
 
Doneraile played minor football recently and are playing minor hurling atm, can check this on the rebel og site. Player in question did play against the Barrs in p1 semifinal and it seems that he's going playing with mallow if rumours are true. Its unfortunate that Doneraile are in such a low state as it wouldn't be nice to see any club fold( can't really see this happening though as they'll probably keep fielding in JB football & hurling to survive), Doneraile beat Ballyclough in JB hurling championship last weekend so there must be some life left in them, also see on the Avondhu website they got beat well by Shanballymore few weeks ago in football championship.
He was listed as a Doneraile player for the Cork Minors this year.

If Doneraile have fielded a minor team this year I'd wonder how he's been allowed transfer to Mallow?

Strange one.

I'm not having a go at the lad btw. The best of luck to him.
 
He was listed as a Doneraile player for the Cork Minors this year.

If Doneraile have fielded a minor team this year I'd wonder how he's been allowed transfer to Mallow?

Strange one.

I'm not having a go at the lad btw. The best of luck to him.
Have we not had enough all week of the player transfer talk on proc?
Plenty possibilities under the rules to enable a transfer .. I don’t know anything about this one but perhaps the 2 obvious possibilities are
1) Player actually lives in the parish and is free to move to them. He played with his 1st club only because he went to primary school there
Or
2) He has transferred to his fathers first club
 
That is 2nd hand information.. I hope that’s right and I’m not wronging anyone. Apologies if I am. Someone from the Barrs told me he was playing for Mallow against them in the minor semi final recently.
Don’t know the lad from Adam but there was a T Kiely playing corner foward for Mallow against the Barrs in the minor semi final
 

Attachments

  • 869BA836-B0C1-4B5D-BD51-20887111CF1E.jpeg
    869BA836-B0C1-4B5D-BD51-20887111CF1E.jpeg
    255.6 KB · Views: 15
EVENT GUIDE - HIGHLIGHT
Home Alone (Pg)
Triskel Arts Centre, Tobin St.

20th Dec 2023 @ 5:45 pm
More info..

John Blek (Extra Show Added)

Coughlan's, Tomorrow @ 7pm

More events ▼
Top