• A reminder that if you give a thumbs up or similarly positive reaction to a racist comment you may also receive a ban along with the user that wrote the post.

FAO Star Trek Fans

Who would win, Enterprise or Voyager?

  • Enterprise

    Votes: 37 56.1%
  • Voyager

    Votes: 17 25.8%
  • Beam me up Sanders

    Votes: 12 18.2%

  • Total voters
    66
Bar the next Generation, they're all shite.

Voyager and DS9 were decent for the most part. Enterprise had one good season.

Discovery and Picard were crap. Making shows 21st century woke is a depressing BBC phenomenon that has made its way onto American networks.
 
Voyager and DS9 were decent for the most part. Enterprise had one good season.

Discovery and Picard were crap. Making shows 21st century woke is a depressing BBC phenomenon that has made its way onto American networks.
Voyager was woke shite. The characters were woeful, Harry, Chakote? I could go on.
DS9 was a soap in space for about 4 years, supposedly it got better then but years of watching Quark in the bar got too much and I checked out.
Enterprise was crap. Quantum Leap meats Star Trek.
Youre giving all of them a free pass because TNG was so good and you like the franchise.
Truth is nearly all the rest were poor.
 
Voyager was woke shite. The characters were woeful, Harry, Chakote? I could go on.
DS9 was a soap in space for about 4 years, supposedly it got better then but years of watching Quark in the bar got too much and I checked out.
Enterprise was crap. Quantum Leap meats Star Trek.
You giving all of them a free pass because TNG was so good and you like the franchise.
Truth is nearly all the rest was poor.

Nah, the dominion storyline in DS9 was as good as anything in TNG.

All the 7of9 stuff was good in Voyager and the doctor.

The Xindi storyline in Enterprise was excellent.

Feel free to disagree but for my money you're wrong.

Picard and Discovery were just rubbish and bore little resemblance to classic trek.
 
Nah, the dominion storyline in DS9 was as good as anything in TNG.

All the 7of9 stuff was good in Voyager and the doctor.

The Xindi storyline in Enterprise was excellent.

Feel free to disagree but for my money you're wrong.

Picard and Discovery were just rubbish and bore little resemblance to classic trek.
How long did it take to get to the dominion story?
I had checked out because it was painful up to that however Ive seen bits and admit they look good. It took way too long to get there.

Voyage Ill have to disagree. I hated most of the crew tbphwy bar the Doc and they had to add a Borg to make it anyway watchable but then ruined it again with the sad sack Harry pining for her.

Ill have to take your word over Enterprise, I found it trite, didnt like the temporal plot, didnt like the music, found the Captain boring, didnt like the Vulcans and checked out before the end of the first series.
 
The Xindi storyline in Enterprise was excellent, there was an alien attack on earth that killed millions and the Enterprise spent a season trying to stop them finishing the job.

Either series 2 or 3, it was quality. Agreed the first series was crap.

U think the dominion stuff might have kicked off in season 3 of DS9? Fishy?
Worf joining the cast helped.

I had a soft spot for Voyager , they had some woeful characters but they gave good Borg. Probably the weakest of the main series but streets ahead of the piss poor Discovery and just not Trek Picard.

Hope the new show returns to Trek values and drops the crash, bang whallop its a star trek show approach.
 
The Xindi storyline in Enterprise was excellent, there was an alien attack on earth that killed millions and the Enterprise spent a season trying to stop them finishing the job.

Either series 2 or 3, it was quality. Agreed the first series wad crap.

I had a soft spot for Voyager , they had some woeful characters but they gave good Borg. Probably the weakest of the main series but streets ahead of the piss poor Discovery and just not Trek Picard.

Hope the new show returns to Trek values and drops the crash, bang whallop its a star trek show approach.

Fuck JJ Abrams.

His films ruined the whole franchise.

There could be some decent action in Star Trek, but it was never about the action. The stories, and the moral dilemmas involved in them were what made it.

And there was social commentary with the Warrior Klingons, the Fascist Cardashians, the rebel Bajorans etc etc.

All these issues could be teased out, without siding with any political parties/viewpoints.
 
Fuck JJ Abrams.

His films ruined the whole franchise.

There could be some decent action in Star Trek, but it was never about the action. The stories, and the moral dilemmas involved in them were what made it.

And there was social commentary with the Warrior Klingons, the Fascist Cardashians, the rebel Bajorans etc etc.

All these issues could be teased out, without siding with any political parties/viewpoints.

Yeah that third New Trek movie is the worst thing in the entire canon.

Absolute garbage.
 
'the third season of Star Trek: Discovery will cover new ground with the addition of two characters: non-binary character Adira, played by actor Blu del Barrio, and transgender character Gray, played by Ian Alexander'.


U wot m8


Star-Trek-Jnaii.jpg



Further proof as if it was needed that the people responsible for Discovery have no knowledge of or appreciation for the show(s) history.

Woke Trek.
 
Last edited:
What's On Today

Live Music

Ballads & Banjos

The Welcome Inn, What's On Today @ 9:30 pm

More events ▼
Top