I think that is a bit harsh. Even though it just pulling and pushing with no blows being struck it was clear that there were going to be players sent off, the melee just went on for too long and with too many players involved for red cards not to be shown.Johnny Murphy was in the refs ear. I wasn't at all surprised two lads got the line when I saw that.
It was a similar situation in the Tipp Galway league game. Lyons was linesman and mad to get a couple of lads sent off after some mild handbags. Thankfully the ref stood firm that night.
You didn't need to a lip reader or body language expert to see by the demeanor of Murphy and Lyons that they wanted blood after those incidents. Honestly they're at another level when it comes to being centre of attention.
If anything it just might help this type of melee from developing, Barrett and Forde were the unlucky pair but it could have been any from about twenty.
I think it shows a new steel in Cork where they are determined not to be pushed around and that is welcome.
If I had a criticism of the officials I think they stood by for too long, I think if they grabbed a couple of players earlier and issued cards it might have finished sooner.
Johnny Murphy was the linesman on the side of the pitch where the pulling started he was always going to be the person who saw most.... far be it from me to defend Johnny Murphy btw.

