Club transfers 2024

[red&blue]

You seem to be well knowledgeable on CNM so can I ask how many transfers in have they had per year recently?

im not familiar witn cill na martra at all, that information is available for anyone to view

ah so now your draconian idea is based on how many players transfer in to a club per year

You’re going to run out of goalposts you’ve moved them so much

there are transfer rules in place which i think are fair and balanced. If a kid is willing to wait a year to transfer theres obviously a strong desire for him to transfer in the first place

 

[Hallbopping]

im not familiar witn cill na martra at all, that information is available for anyone to view

ah so now your draconian idea is based on how many players transfer in to a club per year

You’re going to run out of goalposts you’ve moved them so much

I’ve moved no goalposts. You’re the one telling me I’m going bury CNM when you’ve just admitted now you’re not familiar with them at all.

I’m sure some kids in the parish go to school in Macroom or Inchigeelagh. And there’s more than one national school on CNM too.

 

[red&blue]

I’ll ask you the same as I asked Henrys.

What are your suggestions for transfer rules?

im not suggesting any transfer rule, the rules as they exist are fair and balanced

 

[Hallbopping]

im not suggesting any transfer rule, the rules as they exist are fair and balanced

So you don’t have an issue with 14 year olds who want to transfer spending 48 weeks off the field?

Fair enough so.

 

[red&blue]

I’ve moved no goalposts. You’re the one telling me I’m going bury CNM when you’ve just admitted now you’re not familiar with them at all.

I’m sure some kids in the parish go to school in Macroom or Inchigeelagh. And there’s more than one national school on CNM too.

how many players per year do you think Cill na Martra have? 5? 15? 50?

 

[Hallbopping]

how many players per year do you think Cill na Martra have? 5? 15? 50?

I genuinely have no idea. Can’t imagine it’s very many. Equally I can’t imagine too many transfer in our out either because in the country especially there’s far more loyalty to your club and in particular your father’s club.

 

[red&blue]

So you don’t have an issue with 14 year olds who want to transfer spending 48 weeks off the field?

Fair enough so.

of course i do from the kids perspective but you cant have kids joining whoever they want whenever they want either

 

[red&blue]

I genuinely have no idea. Can’t imagine it’s very many. Equally I can’t imagine too many transfer in our out either because in the country especially there’s far more loyalty to your club and in particular your father’s club.

so transferring is not your issue, what is?

 

[Hallbopping]

of course i do from the kids perspective but you cant have kids joining whoever theh want whenever they want either

I acknowledge it can be harsh in application but honestly I do think it’s stops smaller clubs from being ripped apart.

 

[Hallbopping]

so transferring is not your issue, what is?

It is my issue. The city is a very different story.