• A reminder that if you give a thumbs up or similarly positive reaction to a racist comment you may also receive a ban along with the user that wrote the post.

2026 Premier Senior Hurling Championship

Yes im sure. We regulary sent lads for both codes. We got a call to see if we had any more. Clubs nominated who they want to send. I presume no club would be silly enough to send too many as it would make a farce of it.

Some counties have completely banned development squad coaches from managing the specific age group their son is playing in to cut down on bias.

But that still leaves the initial club nomination stage where the bias is much harder to police.

So to sum up, even the organisation itself recognises the problem is there.
 
Some counties have completely banned development squad coaches from managing the specific age group their son is playing in to cut down on bias.

But that still leaves the initial club nomination stage where the bias is much harder to police.

So to sum up, even the organisation itself recognises the problem is there.
Meath have but that has nothing to with Cork though....just saying like 👍
 
With all due respect, he is completely wrong IMO about the age band. Clare are bio-banding as Henry says, there are a few other counties playing around with it also, but it is absolutely not the kind of system you go and judge after a year or two. NZ rugby is the poster boy for the concept, which keeps the biggest players playing against kids their own size, and equally the smallest players playing against smaller guys. 14-16 is the age band where the widest physical differential exists IMO, you have man children with adult bodies and beards hurling against kids that haven’t even started puberty, and with that comes an enormous gap in weight, height, strength, physicality etc that gives the biggest youngfellas an enormous advantage. On the other side of it you have outstanding technical hurlers who are being blown off the sliotar and finding it hard to compete because they are so under powered. They struggle in the ruck, tackle, in the air etc because they are overpowered, not because they can’t execute those skills very well. The concept of bio banding is that all of these kids train in their own environment and they will still have all of those skills plus the additional size when puberty hits in - eventually it all evens out and you are left with the best overall hurlers, including guys that would have been discarded early in the process otherwise. Similarly the biggest kids are banded with guys their own size so they can no longer rely on the physical advantage they had and is forces them to become technically better, earlier.


To be honest from what Ive seen you can take a traditional approach, or the bio banding approach, or any approach you like, but the biggest difference of all will only be made by the adults in charge of all of this being disciplined in their approach to development squads and making sure they are for development and not winning. Making them about winning achieves nothing at all, no one should really care who won the U15 tournament if you are serious about developing those boys, because if you want to win it you need to make decisions about the make-up of that squad, playing times, dropping talented kids etc now and embracing the bigger, more physical kids generally, when you are supposed to be looking 2 years down the road - those are not compatible concepts. Counties with similar thinking will find each other out, and counties who want to win the Forristal etc can go and do that
superb post
 
superb post
Would be interesting to see it have a trial in some clubs. Even just from a training perspective. Could use 13s/14s and 15s/16s. Would take a few years to see results but would be very interesting to see the numbers and quality that reaches that clubs Adult teams.

Bio-Band for training and play matches at your own age. Or if you had a few clubs willing to trial, have mini leagues, blitzes and a championship style tournament etc through the year.
 
Would be interesting to see it have a trial in some clubs. Even just from a training perspective. Could use 13s/14s and 15s/16s. Would take a few years to see results but would be very interesting to see the numbers and quality that reaches that clubs Adult teams.

Bio-Band for training and play matches at your own age. Or if you had a few clubs willing to trial, have mini leagues, blitzes and a championship style tournament etc through the year.
Clare are getting hockeyed at IC development squad level since they brought in this system. Why would any club team trial it when they are underage county titles, feiles at stake and they train together as a team to win these titles?
Next years Clare minor team will give an early indication.
 
Would be interesting to see it have a trial in some clubs. Even just from a training perspective. Could use 13s/14s and 15s/16s. Would take a few years to see results but would be very interesting to see the numbers and quality that reaches that clubs Adult teams.

Bio-Band for training and play matches at your own age. Or if you had a few clubs willing to trial, have mini leagues, blitzes and a championship style tournament etc through the year.
I don’t think it would work well at club level for a few reasons - the kids at club level are competing, in the end sport is about competition and the majority of players dont end up involved at county level at any age grade so its important to keep competition alive for them IMO. Also this really applies most to U14-16 so thats exactly when Championhip and Feile happens which is a great thing for any kid playing

Also, the issue of the physical gap between players obviously happens at club level but it is less pronounced because every club will generally have a mix of players, obviously bigger clubs get more big guys but its still only a few and not a massive issue. It is far more pronounced when you get a development squad together as you get a concentration of the strongest players and with that comes a concentration of monsters. If you then indulge those kids and try to build winning teams stacked with them the majority of smaller guys haven’t a hope of competing really and get squeezed out

I think it’s much easier to make that development squad environment about development than at club level because you are offering those players something else that they can buy into while they still have their club matches and ambitions. Every training session and match day is still at twice the pace of club, with top level coaching and all of the other aspects of it be that nutrition, S+C, psychology etc etc. Approx 10% of an U14 or U15 development squad will go on to play senior for the county, so what is the point in prioritising competition instead of development with that group?
 
You would have to look back and ask yourself how Joe Deane, Seanie McGrath or Tommy Walsh became the super players they were. You would often hear IC players saying their development came from games in their gardens with older siblings, even camoige players playing against their brothers. Mine regularly go at it with hurlogs and they be smashing each other in to walls in the halls of the house.
 
What's On Today

DJ / Nightlife

Beer Pong

Old Oak, What's On Today @ 9:00 pm

More events ▼
Top