Best PFA Player of the Year? 1974 - 2012

[CORKBHOY]

Originally Posted by Evra

Fine

lol


One less hissy fitter to put up with.


Are you going to take KD with you or is he allowed participate?

[Evra]

Originally Posted by CORKBHOY

Edit: This isn't about who won trebles or what team won the most trophy's.

John O Shea won shit loads. Paul McGrath, not a whole lot.

But Paul McGrath is on the list. John O Shea isn't.


See the logic of this?

Yes

I was telling someone why Ginola won it

Read it again

a bit slower this time

[delzer]

Originally Posted by CORKBHOY

lol


One less hissy fitter to put up with.


Are you going to take KD with you or is he allowed participate?

[CORKBHOY]

Originally Posted by Pattie O Slabs

Shut up ya prick.

This is the wrong place to lose the run of yourself.

Just spotted this.


Steve is a fine poster and shouldn't be spoken to like this.


If this sort of language continues I'll have no option but to ask you to refrain from participation.

He might be trying to drag the thread off track and I have no problem with lads pulling him on it but a bit of decorum goes a long way.

Keep it clean.


Cheers.

CB.

[The Curious Lozenge]

no paul "the player's player" scholes?

[DogTheLangerHunter]

Originally Posted by CORKBHOY

If you think it's pointless I have no problem not including your nominations or vote.

Up to yourself.



Edit: This isn't about who won trebles or what team won the most trophy's.

John O Shea won shit loads. Paul McGrath, not a whole lot.

But Paul McGrath is on the list. John O Shea isn't.


See the logic of this?

To be clear, the point of these initial discussion threads are to facilitate a wide ranging discussion on the subject. In the best manager thread for example there was a good few pages of discussion about books on the old Holland teams that had nothing to do with who was the best manager.

So, stop WUMing.

My nominations are Van Nistelrooy and Bergkamp.

[KD Langer]

Originally Posted by The Curious Lozenge

no paul "the player's player" scholes?

This is not a "manyoo" thread lozzy.

Please keep your anti "manyoo" nonsense out of it.

There are many players on the list that we would all like to discuss without this becoming another big wum, thank you very much.

Feel free to pst up your noms and your reasons why , however.

[The Curious Lozenge]

Originally Posted by KD Langer

This is not a "manyoo" thread lozzy.

Please keep your anti "manyoo" nonsense out of it.

There are many players on the list that we would all like to discuss without this becoming another big wum, thank you very much.

Feel free to pst up your noms and your reasons why , however.

didn't stop you spamming the player of the year thread with your carrick nonsense.

but i will keep to the topic.

[aghabullogue 1890]

Brady & McGrath for me

[The Curious Lozenge]

Originally Posted by CORKBHOY

Year--------- Player------------------- Club
1973–74 Norman Hunter Leeds United
1974–75 Colin Todd Derby County
1975–76 Pat Jennings Tottenham Hotspur
1976–77 Andy Gray Aston Villa
1977–78 Peter Shilton Nottingham Forest
1978–79 Liam Brady Arsenal
1979–80 Terry McDermott Liverpool
1980–81 John Wark Ipswich Town
1981–82 Kevin Keegan Southampton
1982–83 Kenny Dalglish Liverpoo
1983–84 Ian Rush Liverpool
1984–85 Peter Reid Everton
1985–86 Gary Lineker Everton
1986–87 Clive Allen Tottenham Hotspur
1987–88 John Barnes Liverpool
1988–89 Mark Hughes Manchester United
1989–90 David Platt Aston Villa
1990–91 Mark Hughes Manchester United
1991–92 Gary Pallister Manchester United
1992–93 Paul McGrath Aston Villa
1993–94 Eric Cantona Manchester United
1994–95 Alan Shearer Blackburn Rovers
1995–96 Les Ferdinand Newcastle United
1996–97 Alan Shearer Newcastle United
1997–98 Dennis Bergkamp Arsenal
1998–99 David Ginola Tottenham Hotspur
1999–00 Roy Keane Manchester United
2000–01 Teddy Sheringham Manchester United
2001–02 Ruud van Nistelrooy Manchester United
2002–03 Thierry Henry Arsenal
2003–04 Thierry Henry Arsenal
2004–05 John Terry Chelsea
2005–06 Steven Gerrard Liverpool
2006–07 Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United
2007–08 Cristiano Ronaldo Manchester United
2008–09 Ryan Giggs Manchester United
2009–10 Wayne Rooney Manchester United
2010–11 Gareth Bale Tottenham Hotspur
2011–12 Robin van Persie Arsenal
CB.

i think ronaldo is the best player on that list at his peak, however i feel he wasn't near his peak at all in those two years. therefore i would nominate henry who is the best striker i have ever seen play in the premiership. i will have to mull over my second nom.