Best 11 that played under Fergie - at United

[Barry K O Bama]

Who are the best eleven (picked in their usual positions) that have played for Fergie at United ?

My choice would be :-

Schmeichel, Gary Neville, Jap Stam, Rio Ferdinand, Denis Irwin, Ronaldo, Bryan Robson, Roy Keane, Ryan Giggs, Cantona, Wayne Rooney.

Hard to exclude Scholes and Beckham but thats the ways its goes.

[glue]

Gary Bailey
Paul Parker, Steve Bruce, Gary Pallister, Arthur Albiston
Andrei Kanchelskis, Stevie Coppell, Bryan Robson, Jesper Olsen
Eric Cantona, Ruud Van Nistelrooy

[REMIMUFC]

Gary Bailey
Paul Parker, Steve Bruce, Gary Pallister, Arthur Albiston
Andrei Kanchelskis, Stevie Coppell, Bryan Robson, Jesper Olsen
Eric Cantona, Ruud Van Nistelrooy


steve coppell never played under fergie you clown,gary bailey might have played twice for him if that, :silly:

[The Zurich Connection]

Mike Reilly was certainly the best ever.

I'd say Steve Bennett would definately deserves a first team place.

[glue]

steve coppell never played under fergie you clown,gary bailey might have played twice for him if that, :silly:

Ok how about Guiliano Maiorano instead?

[kipto]

Mike Reilly was certainly the best ever.

I'd say Steve Bennett would definately deserves a first team place.

David Ellery was also a consistant performer..especiall y at home

[kipto]

David Ellery was also a consistant performer..especiall y at home

although I can never remember him making much of an impact in Europe...bit like Cantona so...

[Lamps]

Beckham would have to be there.

For me in the traditional 4-4-2, no wumming involved.

Rudolph
Neville Pally Stam Irwin
Becks Robson, Scholes, Ronaldo
Hughes, Van Nistleroy

[daithi81]

Taibi

G. Neville
Baldy French Guy
Wes Brown
P. Neville

Poborsky
Djemba X2
Kleberson
Veron

Bellion
Forlan

[Barry K O Bama]

Taibi

G. Neville
Baldy French Guy
Wes Brown
P. Neville

Poborsky
Djemba X2
Kleberson
Veron

Bellion
Forlan

The 'Baldy French Guy' that you are referring to is probably William Prunier.

[Barry K O Bama]

Beckham would have to be there.

For me in the traditional 4-4-2, no wumming involved.

Rudolph
Neville Pally Stam Irwin
Becks Robson, Scholes, Ronaldo
Hughes, Van Nistleroy

Are u being serious here Lamps ? Fergie rates Roy Keane and Eric Cantona as the two best players that he had at United - also the two most influential. No place for Ryan Giggs either ?

[Lamps]

Are u being serious here Lamps ? Fergie rates Roy Keane and Eric Cantona as the two best players that he had at United - also the two most influential. No place for Ryan Giggs either ?

I'm always serious.

Robson was a better player than Keane.
Ronaldo is an infinitely superior player to Giggs. Becks at his peak would have to be in there, that means no Giggs.
Cantona was a bottler on the big stage. He shat his load against the likes of Monaco and Dortmund.

[Up For The Ba]

.................... ..........1: Schmiechel

2: Irwin.............4: Pallister........... .5: Stam..............3: Evra

7: Beckham............. 6: Keane........8: Scholes.........11: Giggs

.................... ....9: Cantona......10: Van Nistelrooy

[Lee Bushwacker]

:cool:
1. Peter Schmiechel.

2. Paul Parker. 4. Gary Pallister. 5. Jaap Stam. 3. Denis Irwin.

7. David Beckham. 6. Bryan Robson. 8. Roy Keane. 11. Ryan Giggs.

9. Eric Cantona. 10. Rudd Van N.

Some difficult omissions here though eg. Steve Bruce, Rio Ferdinand, Brian McClair, Paul Scholes Mark Hughes and Cristiano Ronaldo.

[scouser]

Schmeichel

Neville Pallister Stam Irwin


Beckham Keane Robson Ronaldo


Hughes Nistelrooy

[daithi81]

Schmeichel

Neville Pallister Stam Irwin


Beckham Keane Robson Ronaldo


Hughes Nistelrooy

Finally, a sensible selection.