PDA

View Full Version : Andy Reid

markinmanc
01-02-2008, 11:11 AM
Bigger traitor than Miller, O'Donovan?
de mange
01-02-2008, 11:24 AM
as in a semi useful irish man?

he is a very talented very unfit player better suited to teh championship because he can get away with it there.. even the bottom prem teams have reserve midfielders that will own him every time due to his fitness and application

having said all that, he is prob one of keanes better signings- by his own standards that is
PatMan
01-02-2008, 11:31 AM
Will be shown up for the over-weight bluffer he is in the Prem League. And £4million? FFS Charlton must be laughing their tits off!
Rebelred
01-02-2008, 11:32 AM
Will be shown up for the over-weight bluffer he is in the Prem League. And £4million? FFS Charlton must be laughing their tits off!

what did Charlton pay for him?
ebenezer
01-02-2008, 12:02 PM
he is a very talented very unfit player better suited to teh championship because he can get away with it there.. even the bottom prem teams have reserve midfielders that will own him every time due to his fitness and application


Will be shown up for the over-weight bluffer he is in the Prem League. And £4million? FFS Charlton must be laughing their tits off!

Andrew Reid is quality.

Best player I've seen at the City Ground in years.
de mange
01-02-2008, 05:07 PM
Andrew Reid is quality.

Best player I've seen at the City Ground in years.

read what i wrote again

i never disputed his ability, however, what i do know is that he can only take 45 mins of a game at a decent level- he is a fat unfit messer

and ive seen him play 15+ times
same thing every time:

starts well some great passing, nice shot or 2, then he starts to fade, and fade, and then its only half time. cue second half anonimity
jimmy magee
02-02-2008, 03:10 PM
the way Keano's signing all the irish lads, you can't help but think he has his mind on promoting Irish players. not very traitorous if you ask me.:)


dunno about Andy Reid, he does seem to fade(or get taken off) when you see him play. good brain for a pass though, and a nice enough touch. might link up well with Jones

Keano's so far spent rashly though. blowing the money like those fuckin brown thomas shoppers, with their several scents and their twenty pairs of shoes.